Case Update | Court Reserves Judgment in Prosecution of Orange Farm ECD Principal Over a Permit She Cannot Obtain

Date: 16/11/2026


Three charged Early Childhood Development (ECD) centre principals attended the Vereeniging Magistrates court on 11th November. However, due to the complexities of the trial, two of their cases were postponed to 20th January 2027 and 3rd February 2027.

 

The trial of Sweetness Marabulela principal of Entokozweni Day Care Centre in Orange Farm Extension 7 proceeded. She is charged with operating a childcare centre without the permit required by Section 100 of the City of Johannesburg public health bylaws. She had been given the option of paying a R5,000 admission of guilt fine, but instead elected to plead not guilty.

Some 60 ECD principals, members of the Sisonke ECD forum, which has a total of 265 members in Region G of Johannesburg (which includes Orange Farm township), attended to support Mrs Marabulela.

She was represented at the court by David Dickinson supported by Madikana Mabulane both from Lawyers for Human Rights.

Mrs Marabulela pleaded not guilty and gave evidence in her defence. Health Inspector Mr Robert Makae who issued the fine gave evidence and was cross examined. LHR subpoenaed Ms Hellen Gqoba, head of the City of Johannesburg’s childcare services, to give evidence. Two expert witness, Mrs Gladys Mokolo, and executive member of Sisonke ECD Forum and Nobukhozi Zulu a law and policy specialist at Real Reform for ECD, gave testimony.

Evidence was led demonstrating that Mrs Marabulela’s ECD centre was on municipal land. Despite having operating the centre for 27 years, Mrs Marabulela has been unable to obtain a lease or agreement from the municipality.

As explained by Ms Gqoba, to start an application for a permit in terms of the City’s bylaws, the applicant must have a title deed to the land or a lease agreement with the title deed owner. This is clearly impossible for Mrs Marabulela, since despite repeated efforts, she has been unable to obtain this from the city.

Thus, the very municipality that has made it impossible for her to obtain a permit are now fining her for not having a permit.

In law, a defence is ‘impossibility.’ In the 2021 Constitutional Court case Van Zyl N.O. v Road Accident Fund it was stated that:

“For a law to be applied as law, compliance must be possible. Conversely and by necessary implication, a law which is impossible to comply with cannot be applied as law… The impossibility principle would apply not only to tasks which are absolutely impossible but tasks which, in the circumstances, are not reasonably capable of performance (Section 54).”

In addition to this defence, Mrs Marabulela’s lawyers argued that, even if she could obtain a lease agreement from the municipality, the costs of providing an architect drawing of the centre (upwards of R10,000) and the fees charged by the municipality (R2,000 to simply open the application process) mean that the impossibility stretched beyond the problem of the lease.

There are 32 children in Mrs Marabulela’s care. Parents pay just R350 per month for their children to attend. Some of the parents cannot afford to pay and Mrs Marabulela covers these with the fees from other children. Three carers are employed by at the centre and the children are provided with careful planned meals. She simply does not have the money that the city demands that ECD principals in poor areas of the city pay.

Evidence from Mrs Marabulela and Mr Makae, the health and safety inspector, confirmed that in terms of health and safety and food hygiene, there were no problems at the Mrs Marabulela’s ECD centre. Indeed, Mrs Marabulela gave evidence as to how she had complied with all instructions from Mr Makae, including having an additional exit from the building constructed to allow for safe evacuation in case of a fire.

The wider issue of public policy were also raised by the expert witnesses. Mrs Mokolo stated, on behalf of Sisonke ECD Forum that of their 265 members, 200 were struggling to get permits. Some have the same problems as Mrs Marabulela. Others don’t have title deeds for their properties, this includes those in informal settlements and in unproclaimed sections of townships where no title deeds exist.

As was stated in the court, if the City of Johannesburg continues with this policy of criminalising ECD principals for what they cannot do, parents in poorer areas of the city will not be able to access affordable childcare facilities. This will leave children unsupervised and open to abuse. It will also mean that they will not receive the critical early educational development that ECD centres provide.

The magistrate reserved judgement which will be given at 8.30am on Wednesday 18th November at the Vereeniging Magistrate’s Court, Court D.

Members of the media are invited to attend and document the delivery of judgment in this matter on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, at 8:30am, at the Vereeniging Magistrates’ Court, Court D.

We also invite media to follow the case and its developments, given its wider implications for ECD practitioners across Johannesburg who face similar barriers in obtaining operating permits, and for families whose access to affordable early childhood education depends on these centres.

For more information, please contact:

David Dickinson (LHR) | David@lhr.org.za | 082 789 1265 

Constance Mkhabeta (Chair of Sisonke ECD Forum) | 084 458 3306 

Nobukhosi Zulu (Real Reform for ECDs) | 074 192 5104 

Thank you for joining
Thank you for joining the LHR Newsletter, we will be in touch soon