Joint Press Statement : The City of Johannesburg failed to provide a lease for 27 years. Now Mam’ Sweetness Marubelela has been convicted for operating without a permit

Date: 18/11/2026


Today, an Orange Farm early childhood development (ECD) principal, Mam Sweetness Marubelela, was found guilty of operating her centre without a permit required under the City of Johannesburg’s public health bylaws.

 

For 27 years, the City has failed to provide Mam Sweetness with the lease she needs to obtain that permit. She repeatedly asked the City for a lease. Today, she has a criminal conviction. 

Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR), Real Reform for ECD, Sisonke ECD Forum and SmartStart are angry and heartbroken at this outcome. Mam Sweetness will appeal her conviction with the support of Lawyers for Human Rights. The court granted leave to appeal, and the appeal is scheduled for 2 December 2026.

What the court decided

The magistrate acknowledged the difficulty of obtaining a permit and criticised the City of Johannesburg for failing to address the longstanding challenges facing ECD centres. Despite this recognition, Mam Sweetness was convicted and sentenced to a fine of R1,000 or 30 days’ imprisonment. The sentence was suspended for five years on condition that she does not operate her ECD centre, one she has been operating for 27 years, without a permit.

“We are deeply disappointed with today’s judgement. While the magistrate castigated the City of Johannesburg for a problem that it knew about, but has failed to address, we had hoped that the magistrate would take on board our legal argument that it was simply impossible for Mrs Marabelela to obtain a permit and dismiss the charge.

“It is because the City of Johannesburg had failed, for 27 years, to provide a lease agreement that Mrs Marubelela is unable to apply for the permit she needs. Because she does not have a permit, the City has now turned her into a criminal. This is unjust and cruel” said David Dickinson, the Lawyers for Human Rights attorney who represented Mam Sweetness

Children in Orange Farm have a right to early childhood development

The charge against Mam Sweetness concerned a missing permit. It did not allege any risk to children’s health or safety. Yet the condition attached to her sentence puts children’s access to early learning and care at risk. For families in Orange Farm who rely on community-based centres, losing a place can mean losing access to affordable childcare altogether.

Children have a right to early childhood development. The City has a responsibility to help centres meet the standards that keep children safe. For Mam Sweetness and other practitioners operating on municipal land, that starts with the City responding to requests for leases and giving practitioners a practical, affordable way to obtain permits.

What needs to happen now

Two other Orange Farm practitioners face similar charges. Their cases, scheduled for January and February, will be postponed by agreement while the appeal is proceeding.

We call on the City of Johannesburg to urgently withdraw all charges against ECD principals and for the City to resolve outstanding lease requests and establish an ECD task team with clear responsibilities and deadlines. Criminal enforcement should be reserved for cases where there is a risk to children’s health or safety, not because of impossible to meet administrative, red-tape, demands. 

David Dickinson added:

“We are determined to take this matter to the highest courts in the land to end this injustice that criminalises poverty.”

Nobukhosi Zulu, Senior Law and Policy Specialist at Real Reform for ECD, who also served as a specialist witness in the case said:

“We invite the City of Johannesburg to urgently reconsider its by-laws. We need a Johannesburg that works with ECDs not criminalises them for requirements that are impossible to comply with.”

LHR, Real Reform for ECD and Sisonke ECD Forum will continue to challenge this conviction and pursue accountability from the City of Johannesburg. Nobody should be punished for the consequences of failures by others.

ENDS

For more information and Media enquiries:

David Dickinson (LHR) | David@lhr.org.za | 082 789 1265 

Constance Mkhabeta (Chair of Sisonke ECD Forum) | 084 458 3306 

Nobukhosi Zulu (Real Reform for ECDs) | 074 192 5104

Thank you for joining
Thank you for joining the LHR Newsletter, we will be in touch soon